Hall of Fame
A four-year starter starting in 2011, Cody Buterbaugh, a second baseman, was named to the PSUAC first team as a junior. He also won the prestigious conference John S. Egli Scholar-Athlete Award with a perfect 4.0 grade point average. Cody repeated on the PSUAC first team selection his senior season and was a USCAA honorable mention that year.
During the three seasons the Buterbaugh brothers played together on the diamond from 2012-14, Penn College baseball teams went a combined 71-42.