Hall of Fame
A center fielder, Zach Buterbaugh earned three-straight PSUAC first team honors from 2012-2014. He was named to the USCAA first team in 2014, when he compiled a .442 batting average and ended the season with a 1.46 earned run average and four saves as a relief pitcher.
During the three seasons the Buterbaugh brothers played together on the diamond from 2012-14, Penn College baseball teams went a combined 71-42.